Exceptions? Errors? In my app_offline.htm? (Gotchas and tips!)

So, app_offline.htm isn’t a fullproof as we’d like. But just to catch up a few people who might be lost already…

What is it? How does it work?

The general idea is that you make a plain-jane html file, name it app_offline.htm, and drop it in the root directory of your ASP.NET website in IIS. IIS automagically knows that if it sees this file, that it should serve it for ALL requests. That way, when you’re doing maintenance, you can have a nice pretty message instead of an application in flux. Great idea right? Yes, it is! Too bad it doesn’t work 100% straightforward that way.

My current understanding (as in, probably wrong) is that IIS only checks for this when serving up ASP.NET content. Which I guess means that IIS isn’t actually doing it at all, but some ASP.NET framework gobbledegook is at some point. This has some pretty serious differences, the two I’ve ran into being that it’s not going to do this for static content requests, and that you have to actually get ASP.NET loaded before this file can be served.

Why I’m running into it

I’ve been working on automated build and deployment scripts for some website applications at work. I have it plugged into our CI server, and we do a lot of QA and UA on the destination environments (note: UA at this stage is done by our internal Product Owner, not an outside client). Since those environments will obviously get messed with whenever we check-in code changes, showing them a nice “under maintenance” to let them know what’s up is a good idea. They know how these servers work, but at least this way they don’t think they uncovered some bug that caused the site to start throwing errors.

We cranked out a quick app_offline.htm, and I worked it into the deploy script. The deployment script works in these steps:

  1. Copy over the app_offline.htm
  2. Delete everything else in the virtual directory (this is done so old pages/usercontrols/files/css/image/etc don’t stay around)
  3. Copy over the new build
  4. Delete app_offline.htm

However, when trying to access the site during this, most of the time you’d just get exceptions. WOW THAT’S WORKING GREAT!

How to avoid issues

First off – since the app_offline.htm done by the ASP.NET framework, it still has to be able to complete initialization. What this means is that if you have a global.asax defined in your web application (and you probably do), it still has to be able to load properly. And if you’re deleting your /bin/ folder before global.asax, then your global.asax can’t finish loading. BAM! Exceptions. This also is important when copying items back over. So, I modified my scripts to delete global.asax FIRST, then everything else. When I’m copying the new build over, I copy /bin/ first, then everything else.

But there’s more!

You’re probably also using a default document. Default.aspx is the one that’s probably actually in your project. If your site’s home page doesn’t have a specific actual page (like 99% of websites), users could just be on http://mysite.com/, and get the “Virtual listing not denied”. Why? Because you’ve deleted Default.aspx, so the ASP.NET processing isn’t happening, so your user gets the “virtual listing not allowed” error. You could add app_offline.htm to the default document rule, but that’s kind of crappy. The real solution here is not to delete Default.aspx. Instead, just copy over it.

My final deployment process

So, now it looks like this:

  • Copy over the app_offline.htm
  • Delete global.asax
  • Delete everything but Default.aspx and web.config (I know those files will ALWAYS exist – so I’m still cleaning out old garbage, but not getting nasty errors)
  • Copy over new /bin/ contents
  • Copy over the rest of the new build
  • Delete app_offline.htm
  • And now I’ve greatly reduced the change for a user to get nasty errors. Why only greatly reduced? Because if they were trying to get to static content, they’ll STILL get 404 (if the old file hasn’t been copied over yet), since the ASP.NET framework isn’t invoked. The solution for that? IIS7 and the integrated pipeline. You’ll want to add this to your web.config:

    <?xml version="1.0"?>
      <configuration>
        <system.webServer>
          <modules runAllManagedModulesForAllRequests="true" />
        </system.webServer>
      </configuration>

    Which is just yet another reason to only copy over your web.config, and not delete it. This setting tells IIS now that ANY requests in this virtual directory should fire the ASP.NET pipeline. However, our servers are IIS6, so we cannot take use of this feature. It’s low risk for us, so it’s not a large deal, but for those of you using IIS7 this is a nice thing to add, especially if you’re using MVC since none of your URLs directly link to an aspx page anyways.

    Hope you find this information useful!

    1 comments:

    danmerino said...

    Good info, didn't expect that there would be a good order when dealing with deleting files and the app_offline.

    Designed by Posicionamiento Web | Bloggerized by GosuBlogger